Best Car Dealers in New York
As of July 2026, CarEdge grades 447 of 2276 New York car dealers from 1,430 verified out-the-door quotes. New York's average doc fee is $220.
281 of 447 rated New York dealers earn an A · 84 earn a D or F
Data updated Jul 11, 2026 · How we score dealers
The Empire State
New York's dealer grade: C
78/100 average transparency score
46th highest doc fees in the U.S.
Based on 447 dealers with verified quotes.
Transparency Leaderboard
View all 2276 dealers →Mastrovito Hyundai
New York Mills, NY
$45 below the New York average
No mandatory add-ons · 12 verified quotes
See the quotesMiddletown Mazda
Middletown, NY
$45 below the New York average
No mandatory add-ons · 11 verified quotes
See the quotesSaratoga Honda
Saratoga Springs, NY
$45 below the New York average
No mandatory add-ons · 5 verified quotes
See the quotesRye Subaru
Rye, NYRye, NY
Suresky Hyundai
Goshen, NYGoshen, NY
Williams Toyota Of Binghamton
Binghamton, NYBinghamton, NY
Romeo Volkswagen
Kingston, NYKingston, NY
Mercedes-Benz Of Rockville Centre
Rockville Centre, NYRockville Centre, NY
Subaru White Plains
Elmsford, NYElmsford, NY
Volkswagen Of Nanuet
Nanuet, NYNanuet, NY
Look up any dealer’s transparency grade
Search 13,000+ dealers by name, brand, city, or zip.
More Dealers in New York
Healey Brothers Cadillac
Newburgh, NY
Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM
Beacon, NY
Healey Ford
Goshen, NY
Healey Lincoln
Goshen, NY
Healey Mitsubishi
Middletown, NY
Heavenly Touch Auto Sales Inc
Middletown, NY
Heights Nissan
Jackson Heights, NY
Helms Bros.
Bayside, NY
Hempstead Lincoln
Hempstead, NY
Hershey's Auto Inc.
Monroe, NY
Hertz Car Sales Smithtown, Ny
Smithtown, NY
Hi Class Auto Sales
Staten Island, NY
Hicksville Auto Sales
Roosevelt, NY
Highline Capital
Deer Park, NY
Highline Cars Show Corp
West Hempstead, NY
Highline Motors Of Westchester Inc.
Ossining, NY
Hillside Auto Sales
Rome, NY
Hillside Motors
Campbell, NY
Hilltop A-1 Auto Sales
Floral Park, NY
Hilltop A-1 Auto Sales
Queens, NY
Dealers by City in New York
New York doc fee law
New York caps dealer documentation fees at $175 by statute. Watch the rest of the quote instead: New York dealers commonly recover margin through add-ons like VIN etching and appearance packages.
New York Dealer FAQ
What is the average dealer doc fee in New York?
As of July 2026, the average documentation fee at 321 rated New York dealers is $220, based on 1,430 verified out-the-door quotes collected by CarEdge. State law caps New York doc fees at approximately $175.
Who are the best car dealers in New York?
Mastrovito Hyundai, Middletown Mazda, Saratoga Honda lead the New York transparency rankings. 281 of 447 rated New York dealers earned an A grade for fair fees, minimal add-ons, and honest pricing.
How are New York dealers graded?
Each dealer is scored 0-100 from verified out-the-door price quotes: fee transparency (30%), add-on behavior (30%), price accuracy (30%), and data quality (10%). Grades update as new New York quotes are verified.
How New York compares to its neighbors
Average doc fees next door. Crossing a state line can change what the dealer charges.
Tips for Buying a Car in New York
- Know the doc fee: The average doc fee in New York is $220. If a dealer charges significantly more, ask them to reduce it or consider other options.
- Good news on add-ons: 77% of dealers in New York charge no mandatory add-ons.
- Get multiple quotes: Request OTD quotes from at least 3 dealers to compare total prices, not just sticker prices.
- Check transparency scores: Dealers with scores above 80 typically have fair doc fees and minimal add-ons.